Don’t Over-Function This Season: A Holiday Guide to Boundaries for People-Pleasers

Line drawing of a seesaw representing people-pleasers' tendency to over-give, especially during the holidays on site for therapy for anxiety, over-unctioning, and people pleasing.

Image via Flaticon

In sessions I often find myself talking with clients, especially those who struggle with people-pleasing and chronic guilt, about what is and is not their “job” in any given relationship. The job analogy, albeit imperfect, helps clarify what they are and, importantly, are not responsible for when interacting with others.

The holidays offer so many opportunities to practice sticking to your “job description” and not taking on emotions, needs, and problems that don’t actually belong to you.


If you struggle with people-pleasing, the holidays tend to bring it out even more

People tend to either love or hate the holidays. While many of my clients love the festivity, connection, and food, they often struggle greatly with navigating the interpersonal dynamics and the pressure of having a “good” Thanksgiving/Hanukkah/Christmas/Kwanzaa/New Year’s, you name it. Those who struggle with chronic guilt especially tend to take on personal responsibility for everyone’s experience.

If you relate, this is for you.

It’s natural to want and try to have an enjoyable holiday! There is nothing inherently wrong with that desire. But things get tricky when we take on internal responsibility for external factors that aren’t really in our control. The analogy of a job description can be helpful for demystifying what is and isn’t really yours to manage.

Let’s get into it.

What you are responsible for over the holidays:

These fall under your “job description,” if you will. Not everything will apply, so take what you need and leave the rest. Comment below if you think of something else I didn’t list or have a question!

You are responsible for being aware of, or at least curious about, what it is you need

Before you have any hope of taking care of your needs, you have to know what they are. For some of us this is easy, but for others it’s a real struggle after identifying for so long as a “giver.”

Think about past holidays that you’ve spent with family or friends. Start by reflecting on what went well. What events happened that led to pleasant emotions for you? Knowing what you enjoy is half the battle!

Second, consider what tends to happen that irks or upsets you. Maybe it’s the presence of certain difficult people who show up, or a specific behavior (think Uncle Jim always being at least 37 minutes late, leaving everyone hangrily waiting to start dinner).

To dig a little deeper, like we do in somatic work, take time to focus on how your body feels as you recall past events you enjoyed, as well as those you would rather forget. Slowing down to experience your body’s reaction can help your needs feel more tangible, making them more real and justifiable to you.

You are responsible for expressing your needs, wants, and desires… or accepting that others will be unable to meet them

Knowing what you need or want is an important first step. Next, it’s time to express it.

A caveat up front: If it’s unsafe for you to express your desires or needs, don’t do it. Only you know what’s best for you deep down. If you are gathering with people connected to your own trauma or abuse, it will be helpful to work with a therapist on an attachment and nervous system-informed approach to standing up for yourself.

There are many ways to express your needs. Verbally, in-person, over text, with actions, nonverbally, and more.

Ideally, you could calmly state, “Grandma, I’m uncomfortable discussing my weight with you,” and she would respectfully move on (Okay, ideally Grandma wouldn’t mention your body at all in the first place, but you catch my drift.)

If you have expressed your needs like that, good for you! That is a huge step and a skill that will serve you well. What I find often happens, though, is that most people think they can say what they need once and their work is done.

But we know that’s not usually the case.

You have to be ready to take your needs seriously, even when others don’t get it right the first time. If you think it will be one-and-done, you’re likely to give up quickly and wind up disappointed and feeling stuck. But if you stick with it, relationships can actually start to change. More on this in the next section.

Lastly, if you are unable or not ready to express yourself directly, you’re not alone. It’s important to weigh out the benefits and risks of expressing yourself and ask: Am I ready for the discomfort I’ll probably feel making this request? Is it worth it to me at this point in time? Are there more important things I’d rather use my energy on?

In this case, you’re responsible for accepting that fact, and its consequences. In other words, you want to work to be okay with the fact that things are not likely to change right now, that you don’t have the bandwidth or confidence to share your needs, and that therefore others can’t understand or meet them (for now).

You are responsible for setting boundaries and actually sticking to them

Importantly, as one of my own former therapists used to say, boundaries are not requests. Confusing the two can really get you stuck.

  • Boundaries – behaviors you have control over executing and maintaining in order to remain in relationship with someone.

  • Requests – behaviors you ask for from others that they can choose to agree to or refuse, which you have no control over.

For example, if we’re thinking about Uncle Jim’s tendency to run late from earlier:

  • A boundary would be deciding to eat before Uncle Jim arrives. Or deciding to eat before you leave for the holiday gathering so you’re not hangry. Or stashing snacks in your pocket and sneaking bites of beef jerky in the bathroom. Or deciding to at least feed your kids before Uncle Jim arrives because then they’re less fussy and everything else feels easier. Each of these is within your control.

  • A request would be asking Uncle Jim to please arrive on time so you can all start eating together. Or asking the whole family if they’re willing to have dinner together before Uncle Jim arrives. None of these are within your control.

Sometimes a request precedes a boundary. You’ve given someone a heads up that you don’t like something or need something specific, and if they don’t accommodate and it’s important enough to you, you move from a request to a boundary.

If we use the above example of Grandma making comments about your body:

  • A boundary would be saying, “Grandma, I’ve shared with you that I don’t like these
    comments. If you keep making them, I’m going to eat at the kids’ table.” Or, more gently, “Grandma, I really enjoy talking with you and value your opinion a lot, but these comments about my body are too much. If you continue to talk about me like that, I will have to keep distance,” then actually keeping your distance. Or not saying anything and just removing yourself when Grandma begins making her comments.

  • A request would be, “Grandma, please don’t talk about my body anymore.”

Once you’ve actually set the boundary, your job is to take it seriously. That means if you tell Grandma you won’t stick around for her commentary, you actually have to walk away.

THIS WILL FEEL WEIRD.

Feeling weird doesn’t mean it’s bad. Anything new or different is going to feel just that — new and different. See if you can recognize and allow that discomfort without letting it deter you. It’s not an either-or, it’s a both-and. Remember, you are going to experience difficult feelings when Grandma makes her comments either way… whether you choose to stick around to hear them or not.

Grandma may have a really negative reaction to this. Managing her reaction is not in your job description. More on that below.


Growing beyond the discomfort

If your discomfort keeps you from asking for what you need, it may be helpful to reach out to someone who specializes in working with people-pleasing. If you’re looking for virtual or in-person therapy in Houston, or virtual therapy across Texas, I’d love to help you with this goal.

Once you’re ready, you can schedule a free 15-minute consultation to get started.


You are responsible for navigating resentment that’s built up from years of over-functioning for others

If your familial role has been taking care of and appeasing others, and it’s led you to read this far down the blog post, you’re probably getting tired of the status quo.

In no way do I blame you for this pattern. No one wakes up one morning deciding to become the human scaffolding supporting their family’s functioning, lest the whole house crumble.

There are common dynamics that lead a person to step into this role, even in early childhood. The bottom line is: now that you’re aware of it, you’re the one who can do something about it.

A difficult fact: it’s often the ones who’ve spent decades over-functioning who have to make a change.

It’s rare for a person who’s used to under-functioning to step up when someone else is there to take care of things for them. While it can feel unfair after all the work and giving you may have done, it’s still your job to step back from people-pleasing or enabling.

No one else can do that work for you.

So as you navigate expressing your needs, making requests, and setting new boundaries, know that there is often a build-up of resentment and grief that comes with recognizing how much you’ve given, and how much you haven’t gotten in return.

What is not your responsibility:

Now that we’ve established your job description, it’s just as important to point out what does not fall under your purview. One of the hardest parts of choosing to change people-pleasing tendencies is knowing what to let go of and trusting that things can be okay even if you’re not (I say this with love) micromanaging them.

You are not responsible for other people’s emotional reactions

Maybe the top challenge for those who struggle with people-pleasing is realizing that it’s not your job to fix other people’s difficult emotions.

I hear the cascade of “But what if XYZs???” overflowing from your mind right now. Let’s get into it.

Common questions:

“But what if my boundary hurt their feelings?”
“But what if they’re doing their best?”
“But what if they don’t know any better?”
“But what if they see me as a bad daughter/spouse/sibling?”
“But what if they still blame me and force their emotions on me?”

Even if all of these things are true, it is still not your responsibility to change someone else’s emotions. And it’s not helpful or kind to do so, even if you’re coming from a good place.

People are entitled to feel how they feel. This is true even when their feelings are based on misunderstandings or irrational thoughts, or when their feelings are in response to your behavior.


When you try to preempt or correct someone else’s feeling, you convey that you don’t trust them to manage their own emotions, which may be fair, but it keeps them from ever having to learn how.


The other person may very well not have emotional regulation skills and experience great difficulty handling your boundary or request. And it’s still not your job to coddle or placate them. Consider how you feel when someone is handling you with kid gloves. Even to someone who’s used to being enabled, deep down it does not feel good. It just feels familiar.

We all keep dancing to the same familiar choreography until one person in the relationship takes a new step. You can only control your own moves. A book that illustrates these concepts so well is The Dance of Anger by Harriet Lerner.

When you change things up, of course the other person will continue the same old dance. That’s what they know. Your job isn’t to swoop in to save them from the shock of something new, it’s to stick to your new moves. That gives the other person actual respect — the chance to be responsible for themselves. What they do with that chance is not on you.

You are not responsible for others’ discomfort when you enforce your boundaries and requests

Building on the last point, other people will likely try to get you to step back into the old routine. They may even try harder than before to see if you crack. This is often not malicious or on purpose. It’s just the way our beautiful and perplexing human brains are built.

Revisiting Grandma

Let’s examine opinionated Grandma again. Assume you’ve shared a request (“Grandma, please don’t make comments about my body. I know you’re coming from a place of love but it makes the holidays more stressful for me.”) and Grandma continued to make comments so you set a boundary (sat at the kids’ table).

Grandma is in rare form tonight. You can hear her making comments from the grownups table about how, “Some people are so sensitive! Good thing I won't be here forever to ‘make things stressful.’” Woof!

You do a great job maintaining your boundary and don’t engage, choosing to focus on the kids. Jenny and Johnny are fighting over a turkey leg, but Breanne is making up an elaborate story about how her butter and roll just got married and the carrot officiated and all the peas are guests, so you hum a song for the butter and roll to have their first dance to. The song is “Baby Got Back.”

Later you get home to find a text from Grandma saying, “It’s too bad we couldn’t talk more at Thanksgiving. I guess that’s just how it will be since I’m so ‘stressful.’ Don’t worry you won’t have to sit next to me at Christmas either.” Ouch.

What do we do with Grandma?

The message hurts, it sucks, it’s not fair… AND it’s a sign that you’re stepping out of the old pattern. Grandma may be hurt too (which is not your fault or responsibility), and anxious about this unfamiliar response. She is also (not intentionally) trying to test your limits and see if you’ll step into the old dance and make it all okay.

But because you know her difficult emotions aren’t in your job description, and you decided you have the bandwidth to maintain your boundary, you’re not going to do that. And it feels weird. Yay — the growing pains of progress!

First, make some room for your own weird feelings. It’s okay, even expected, for them to be here, and you have the skills to sit with them. Once you’ve given space to your own needs, you’re ready to decide what to do about Grandma.

You have a few options:

  • Say nothing. You don’t have to say anything if you don’t want to. Only you know how this is likely to pan out. But know that you don’t owe her further response for any reason if you don’t want to give it. Continue to hold your boundary at future gatherings.

  • Redirect. You might choose not to engage with her acting out in response to your boundary, while still keeping the conversation going. This could sound like, “I always love seeing you and I’m looking forward to Christmas. Maybe we can time Uncle Jim together lol. Love you!” Hope she takes your request seriously at Christmas, and if not, repeat your boundary of not hanging around her as much around dinnertime.

  • Be direct. You can also reassert what you need, and you have so many options for how to approach this ranging from very matter-of-fact to validating and warm. This might look like, “Hey Grandma, I’m glad we got to see each other tonight. I always want to be able to spend time with you at these gatherings, but when you talk about my body it makes it hard for me. I hope you can respect that, and I look forward to seeing you at Christmas.” Continue to hold your boundary next time if it comes up.

    If it feels aligned and you have the bandwidth, you can always offer to have a deeper discussion about it. But you don’t have to!

You are not responsible for maintaining the status quo

If you’ve always been someone who tries to appease, keep others happy, and be “easy,” you might feel like you’re not allowed to pivot into having needs. As if it would be too sudden, and people would be too disappointed.

Often in our work together, clients who struggle with people-pleasing say things like, “But I’ve always done XYZ,” as a reason not to change, even when doing XYZ makes them feel resentful, invisible, or unhappy. Familiarity feels safer.

Responding to external pressure

Sometimes, as in above, the pressure to maintain the status quo comes from within. Often, though, those around you are explicitly or implicitly sending you messages to keep playing your part. Just to reiterate, this is rarely malicious or purposeful. We just tend to default to our “factory settings,” and when things change or become stressful, this is even more true.

Let’s think about Grandma again.

Imagine you’ve made your request, set your boundary, and maintained it. Then the next time you see your mom, she brings up her mom. “You know she’s just old fashioned. You can’t expect her to change!”

If you struggle with people-pleasing, you’re probably already feeling some level of internal pressure to cave. You stayed strong through Grandma’s external pressure, but when Mom adds more, it can feel like you’re disappointing so many people. You might have thoughts like, “I’m being difficult. I could just ignore the comments and move on. I shouldn’t have said anything. I’m not a good daughter or granddaughter.”

That’s a normal process to go through when you’re starting to stand up for yourself. Being asked to “change back” is a sign you’re doing something different. So is being uncomfortable.

Important reminder: You are not responsible for Mom and Grandma’s relationship.

You’re also not responsible for the fact that they’re talking about you. That’s their choice. But you are not the one who got Mom involved, Grandma is. And now Mom is pressuring you to be easy and smooth it over.

But here’s the thing: Grandma pressuring Mom is between the two of them. Your boundary with Grandma is between the two of you. Don’t cross the streams.

You can use the wording examples above to make requests/set limits with Mom just like you did with Grandma.

The important thing is to remember that by asking someone not to make comments about your body, you’re not doing anything wrong. Even if they don’t like it and act weird to you afterward.

If you’ve spent much of your life feeling responsible for others’ emotions, this will be hard to believe. Notice that it feels difficult. See if you can sit with that, giving those feelings space and time to be felt. And then, still keep the boundary anyway.

Their feelings are their job, your boundary is your job, and maintaining the status quo is nobody’s job because it doesn’t seem to be working!


Congratulations, you’re hired for the job you never applied for!

Many of us recovering people-pleasers have our work cut out for us this holiday season. Setting and maintaining boundaries can feel even harder around the holidays due to stress and external pressure, but that almost makes it more important.

To recap, let’s review what’s in your job description:

  • Becoming aware of your own needs

  • Expressing your needs, wants, and feelings (and accepting that if you’re not ready to do so, others won’t understand or act on them)

  • Managing grief and resentment from over-functioning and under-receiving

  • Setting boundaries and sticking to them

What isn’t in your job description:

  • Managing or changing others’ emotional reactions to your requests and boundaries

  • Acquiescing to and placating others’ discomfort when they (inevitably) push back against your boundaries

  • Maintaining the status quo and being “easy” or “good”

Whether you want extra support navigating the murky waters of interpersonal dynamics during the holidays, or plan to work on people-pleasing less as a New Year’s resolution, I’d love to help. If you’re looking for therapy in Houston or virtually in Texas, I hope you reach out.

Next
Next

Do I Have to Process My Trauma? How to Know if Trauma Therapy is Right for You